Archive for game design

when does tragedy = gameplay?

The tragedy of the commons is an economics theory, according to which individuals, acting independently and rationally according to each one’s self-interest, behave contrary to the whole group’s long-term best interests by depleting some common resource. 

Take an example of overfishing. Every fisherman knows that if there is too much fishing then eventually fish stocks will run out. If all the fishermen could agree to fish at sustainable levels then the fish stocks could last forever. However, if one fisherman starts to overfish then eventually the fish stocks will run out.

When this happens the others might as well overfish as well to get as much as possible before the stocks run out. It only takes someone to start overfishing to mean that it is then logical for everyone else to overfish. The first person might start because they think that just them overfishing will not make any difference but once they start then everyone else soon joins them and the stocks run out.
This is similar to the prisoners’ dilemma. However in the prisoners’ dilemma individuals cannot communicate and so, if they act logically, then they won’t co-operate with the other players and will end up with a worse outcome. In the tragedy of the commons everyone can communicate but it still leads to a situation where a collective resource is overused.

There are some great gameplay opportunities lurking in this kind of model.
Especially where information is limited in some way, and there are competing personal goals that are not always clear to all players.

Leave a Comment

too busy to watch the ads on TV

Should game session length mirror the length of ad breaks on TV?

“While 50 percent of DVR users would routinely skip ads, “the number is declining now,” said Poltrack, “because they’re too busy on their phones to fast-forward through the ads,” given that two-thirds of users watch TV while also engaged with a second screen.

http://www.adweek.com/news/television/dont-panic-says-cbs-more-people-are-watching-tv-now-decade-ago-166313
via http://ben-evans.com

Leave a Comment

if you decide to be in the dog food business…

Be delighted to eat dog food.

It makes no sense to disdain the choices your customers make. If you can’t figure out how to empathize and eagerly embrace the things they embrace, you are letting everyone down with your choice. Sure, someone needs to make this, but it doesn’t have to be you.

If you treat the work as nothing but an obligation, you will soon be overwhelmed by competition that sees it as a privilege and a calling

http://sethgodin.typepad.com/seths_blog/2014/08/if-you-choose-to-be-in-the-dog-food-business-.html

Leave a Comment

politicians use the focusing effect

The Focusing Effect – People place too much importance on one aspect of an event and fail to recognize other factors
http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/236681

Could be useful when thinking about presenting choices to the player in negotiations, where the information we provide doesn’t have to be ‘fair’. In most circumstances you want the UI information provided to the player to fairly represent the data and encourage a reasonable skilled choice from the player. In negotiations, or in situations of political will, the ‘character’ wants to manipulate the player and can lie, cheat and skew the information that they present to the player. It is then up to the player to use their knowledge, skill, perception etc to understand the situation in front of them.

“Nothing In Life Is As Important As You Think It Is, While You Are Thinking About It” – Daniel Kahneman

Read the rest of this entry »

Leave a Comment

pick the right number of choices

Every choice takes some mental energy. Make the choices you offer the player ones that matter and that they should care about. Don’t make them burn energy on thinks that don’t matter or aren’t meaningful. 

The only thing worse than never having a choice is always having to choose 

Leave a Comment

the role of a whip in political games

Thinking about the possible roles in a multiplayer game with a more political aspect. Player’s will need to organize, recruit and remind players of their goals etc. This matches the real world role of a whip.

A whip is an official in a political party whose primary purpose is to ensure party discipline in a legislature. Whips are a party’s “enforcers,” who typically offer inducements and threaten party members to ensure that they vote according to the official party policy.

 A whip’s role is also to ensure that the elected representatives of their party are in attendance when important votes are taken. The usage comes from the hunting term “whipping in,” i.e. preventing hounds from wandering away from the pack. In the United States there are legislatures at the local (city councils, town councils, county boards, etc.), state, and federal levels. The federal legislature (Congress), state legislatures, and many county and city legisltive bodies are divided along party lines and have whips

Leave a Comment

YouTube and Twitch are part of the game designers ecosystem

“Because there’s so much awesome stuff that’s happening on YouTube, the videos that people are posting, the amazing creations that people are making on Minecraft, all the League of Legends stuff – this didn’t exist before. I think the innovation is just happening in a place where it might be a little bit outside of the control of the developer.”

Leave a Comment

thinking about delighting users

“That’s been really the challenge that I’ve been suffering: how can we look at the business differently rather than thinking about ARPU’s, what the numbers are, what knobs to turn etc? Instead, we should be thinking about what experiences can we deliver that are going to delight users. The crazy thought that I was giving with the talk today was I believe that there are going to be companies out there that really practice and really understand the value of user experience over time.

Leave a Comment

600% more time spent in multi-player than single player

I can tell you that Steam users have put an aggregate of about 3.8 billion hours into Dota 2. I can tell you that Steam users tend to put nearly 600 percent more time into the multiplayer mode on Modern Warfare 2 than the single player mode.

http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2014/04/introducing-steam-gauge-ars-reveals-steams-most-popular-games/

Leave a Comment

think twice before using ingrained conventions

Game developers should think twice before including ingrained game conventions such as combat, death, and trial-and-error gameplay. Trial and error in games undermines emotional experiences and “keeps the machinery opaque.” It is un-immersive because it “chips away at the make-believe,” forcing the player to examine the game machinery to figure out how to beat the system.

and a really interesting blog post about Indie games as inspiration
http://www.theastronauts.com/2012/10/reboot-your-aaa-brain/

 

Leave a Comment

are tablets really PCs?

Interesting article on tablet trends – http://ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2014/4/25/ipad-growth

  • iPad sales are slowing and pretty flat.
  • Apple still winning, and Android tablets not cause of slow down
  • Is it because iPads can’t be used for the same stuff as PCs yet?

…moving to new devices and form factors involves new software experiences, and new software also often both creates and requires new business processes. It’s hard to spend a day creating a 20-slide sales report on an iPad, even now that MS Office is available for iPad. But actually, that sales report should be a SAAS dashboard that takes 10 minutes to annotate. It will take time for those business processes to shift to enable more corporate tablet use.

Maybe suggesting that software will need to keep moving forward to meet the changing needs. In games, tablet games have been very much thrown in with phones most of the time. Unique tablet games will likely have more in common with PC than smartphone.

So, looking at tablets and smartphones as mobile devices in a new category that competes with PCs may be the wrong comparison – in fact, it may be better to think of tablets, laptops and desktops as one ‘big screen’ segment, all of which compete with smartphones, and for which the opportunity is just smaller than that for smartphones. And so tablets will over time eat away at laptop and desktop sales just as laptops ate away at desktop sales, but the truly transformative new category is the smartphone. Maybe.

We need to think about the tablet as part of the ‘PC’ and think about what it does to gamers expectations, and what we have to do to innovate in this space.

An alternate selection of data from Reality Mine on tablet use throughout the day, where and what people are doing with their tablets in 2014.
Tablets used most between 8 & 9pm primarily for content consumption, with games and entertainment apps leading the pack.

  • Apps, TV and Video content consumption are top activities for tablet owners.
  • Gaming is the most popular activity on tablets, compared to social networking for mobile phone users.
  • 85% of all tablet use occurs at home, this is significantly more than in home use of tablets and computers.
  • The majority of people are ‘relaxing’ while using their tablet or iPad.

 

Leave a Comment

tension cycles

Extra Credit’s ‘How horror games create tension cycles’

Leave a Comment

CRAM in more powerful tension and horror

  • Cliches
    Cliches from film and books, can be over-used. However, while they can telegraph a potential outcome they will create an atmosphere and tell your players something about what to expect and how to behave. They create a form of anticipation. Use them to set the tone, switch them up to avoid over-use or removing any surprise from the plot.
  • Relationships
    Relationship is the connection that the player has to other characters, to the story and to the environment. Creating space for players to create and form relationships can be challenging in a fast paced or action story.
    Look for opportunities for shared experiences that create emotional connections. Some of the strongest bonds that people have are established throug highly emotional circumstances that release chemicals in to the player’s mind.
  • Anticipation and Pacing
    Anticipation is everything and is key to building any kind of tension in your game. Build and release, repeat. Consider foreshadowing as a means to create anticipation – Checkov’s gun
  • Moral decision
    Moral = ‘of or concerned with the judgment of right or wrong of human action and character’
    It is likely to be a point in time, at which the players have to consider their situation, the story, their relationships and character. Explicit choice is good for a game. And a situation with consequences leads to a meaningful choice that player’s will remember.

http://www.worldofleveldesign.com/categories/level_design_tutorials/horror-fear-level-design/part1-survival-horror-level-design-cliches.php

Ultimately it all need wrapping together in a good story

  • Story is king
    The power of story in your level comes down to two things. The story of the environment; and character’s story in that environment. As well as the relationship between each other.
    Story is what we remember. We love to tell stories. We love to listen to stories. There is no better way to communicate and to connect with someone. We don’t care about facts.
    Look for ways to tie the environment and story together, select the environment carefully to add to the mood and atmosphere.

Leave a Comment

rules for designing choices

Great article on designing choices, rules 1 and 2 are critical IMO

  1. Every option should have real consequences
  2. The player needs some basis to make a decision
  3. No option should be obviously better or worse than all the others
  4. Know your players
  5. Break these rules

https://www.choiceofgames.com/2010/03/5-rules-for-writing-interesting-choices-in-multiple-choice-games/

Leave a Comment

keep it deep

Chu said that Blizzard distinguishes between complexity and depth. It wants players to enjoy games, like World of Warcraft in its 10th year, for decades. It enables that through depth, but not complexity.

Complexity is about all the different things you need to understand before you can make decisions in the game. Depth gives you a wide range of options to take once you understand the game.

The best tricks that Hearthstone's game designers used to make Blizzard's latest megahit

design language : deep simplicity

 

Leave a Comment

shiny things are wet

glossywater

“The evidence that people are drawn to shiny things is all around us: from the pages of lifestyle magazines to the page stock of lifestyle magazines. One logical explanation for this cultural affection is that we’ve come to associate gloss with wealth and luxury.”

“… that our preference for glossy might be deep-rooted and very human,” says Patrick. “It is humbling to acknowledge that despite our sophistication and progress as a species, we are still drawn to things that serve our innate needs–in this case, the need for water.”

http://www.fastcodesign.com/3024766/evidence/an-evolutionary-theory-for-why-you-love-glossy-things

Leave a Comment

entertain them

“Don’t make people pay for entertainment. Entertain them so that they will pay.”

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/6552/the_design_of_freetoplay_games_.php

Leave a Comment

do we need to care about technology any more?

“Talk about experiences, not features. Technology is there to enable an experience, and as long as it doesn’t get in the way, most consumers would rather not worry about it.”

http://www.fastcodesign.com/1671910/the-12-trends-that-will-rule-products-in-2013

Leave a Comment

simple ideas

“Simple ideas are easier to understand. Ideas that are easier to understand are repeated. Ideas that are repeated change the world. “

Simon Sinek

Leave a Comment

cooperation is our species’ signature adaptation

“Cooperation is our species’ signature adaptation”

Headline quote from a Fast Company article inspired by Harvard biologist E.O. Wilson’s book The Social Conquest of Earth.

http://www.fastcompany.com/1843210/your-startup-is-a-tribe-and-your-customers-are-members

Leave a Comment

Older Posts »